I read two different, very different books by the same author. At first I wasn't even sure if it was the same author, as they are so different and may attract completely different audiences. I absolutely do not understand how the author choose to use the same name to publish both books.
Let's start with the bad one.
Fimbulwinter is fantasy, almost pornographic, and a wet dream for the archetypical D&D male nerd who dreams of being a magician. It's what happens to the main character, Daniel Black, who ends up being an overpowered and somewhat arrogant wizard in another universe. Conjuring tits and having sex with demons. (And which male reader wouldn't want that!)
Surprisingly (or perhaps not so) it attracts a certain audience, and actually turned into a series of books. (I think five or so by now.) I don't mind some 'carnal' elements if it supports the story, but here it is half the story.
What's so sad about it is that A Perilous Waif, also by Brown's hand, is great. It just makes no sense, but how could I direct someone to A Perilous Waif, knowing that that same reader would look for other books by the same author, and then would end up with this garbage?
Perhaps it is just me and this is a great work and I'm too prude. I like Game of Thrones but I find it a little too explicit as well now and again. It must be me. I am the incarnation of prude. It's either that, or the book is just rubbish.
The verdict? Only suitable for hormonal driven young boys / men who like their D&D dreams to become reality. As for the obligatory disclaimer: personal opinion etcetera etcetera.
I'm actually happy I can say some very positive things about his other book which I read... If Brown ever reads this review at least he might appreciate that.
A Perilous Waif
A Perilous Waif might almost be called YA, it's science fiction, has a likeable protagonist, and is surprisingly fresh. Even the cover is great and matches the story. (A rare thing indeed.)
The main character is Alice Long, an orphan with some very advanced cybernetic and DNA enhancements. Everybody has those, but hers are a bit... different. When she gets older she develops some interesting capabilities, and the (very) advanced technology actually makes some sense...
- Pre-programmed DNA and cybernetics that develop as the child grows up
- Artificial intelligence
- Robots, replicators, clones
- Japanese mafia
- Cloned personalities, virtual avatars (copies of people in other bodies or machines)
- Some good fights, small scale and large scale
- Spaceships, planet hopping, FTL, hyperspace, you name it, it's all there
- A coming of age story, a love story, an 'uncover hidden past story', and some quests for loot, all rolled into one
It may not all be believable, but it is a lot of fun!
There's a second book coming up, but this book is great as it is and doesn't need a follow-up. Let's hope the author manages to keep it in the same vein and style and the walls between Alice Long's and Daniel Black's universes stay in place, literally as well as stylishly.
I'm still baffled by the difference in the tone between the two books... I even checked out the author's website to make sure that was the case. It is. I still can't believe it.
But... how can I suggest A Perilous Waif to my teen daughter, with the risk of her picking up Fimbulwinter as well? What will people think of me when I suggest them a E. William Brown book? Sigh.
So please pick up and read A Perilous Waif and let's not think to much about that other book...
Dapper / TellTales! 96